
Direct vs Funds: The Allocation Shift Continues
In this episode, we examine Direct vs Funds: The Allocation Shift Continues.
Backing a company directly gives investors a say in exactly where their capital goes. Investing through a fund places selection and ongoing management with a professional team. Both approaches involve trade-offs, and combining them brings its own considerations.
We explore the role of co-investments, the costs beyond headline fees, and why diversification and liquidity deserve separate scrutiny. Drawing on Australian examples, we consider what these choices mean for wholesale and sophisticated investors building their private market exposure.
This discussion provides general information only and does not constitute personal financial advice.
Chapter 1
Introduction
PrimaryMarkets Male
Welcome to Unlocking Liquidity, the PrimaryMarkets podcast exploring the opportunities and challenges shaping private markets.
PrimaryMarkets Male
For investors in private markets, choosing an asset is only part of the decision. Choosing how to own it can be equally consequential.
PrimaryMarkets Male
A commitment to a private equity or venture capital fund places investment selection, portfolio construction and much of the ongoing oversight with a professional manager. A direct investment gives the investor a more specific choice: which company to back, at what valuation and on what terms. Between those approaches sits a growing range of co-investments, syndicates and secondary transactions, each combining different levels of discretion, access and responsibility.
PrimaryMarkets Male
For wholesale and sophisticated investors, the allocation debate is therefore becoming more detailed. The question is how much capital to delegate, where to retain investment discretion and whether the potential benefits of greater involvement justify the additional work.
PrimaryMarkets Male
The allocation shift continues, but its direction is more nuanced than a simple movement out of funds and into individual companies. The evidence points towards a market in which both approaches have a role, with investors facing closer decisions about the structure best suited to each opportunity.
Chapter 2
A Shift Towards More Deliberate Allocation
PrimaryMarkets Male
Claims that direct investing is universally displacing funds deserve scrutiny. The UBS Global Family Office Report 2026 recorded average 2025 portfolio allocations of 8% to direct private equity and 9% to private equity funds and funds of funds. Both channels remained meaningful components of the surveyed portfolios. These are global family office findings, rather than a measure of Australian wholesale investor behaviour, but they provide useful context for the debate.
PrimaryMarkets Male
The practical implication is that direct and fund investing can coexist within the same portfolio. An investor may value a manager’s access to overseas buyouts while preferring to assess an Australian growth company personally. Another may use a venture capital fund for early-stage exposure and consider individual secondary purchases in more established businesses.
PrimaryMarkets Male
This makes the allocation decision specific to the investor’s capabilities and the opportunity in front of them. Sector knowledge, available capital, time, access to information and capacity to absorb losses all influence which structure is appropriate.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Greater choice is valuable. It also makes a consistent investment process more necessary.
Chapter 3
Why Direct Investment Appeals
PrimaryMarkets Male
Direct investment allows capital to be allocated to a defined business. Investors can assess its products, management, competitive position and financial requirements before deciding whether to participate. Their exposure is shaped by that decision, rather than by a manager’s subsequent selection of companies within a broader mandate.
PrimaryMarkets Male
For investors with relevant operating experience, this can be attractive. Someone who has built a logistics business may be better placed to evaluate a supply-chain technology company than an unfamiliar biotechnology platform. Industry knowledge can help an investor challenge assumptions about customer adoption, pricing, capital expenditure and commercial execution.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Direct investment also offers greater discretion over the amount committed to a particular opportunity. Investors can decline a transaction that appears expensive, avoid sectors already well represented in their portfolio and decide whether a company’s development stage matches their objectives.
PrimaryMarkets Male
However, discretion over investment selection should not be confused with control over the company. A minority shareholder may have limited influence over strategy, future fundraising or the timing of an exit. Board representation, information rights and shareholder protections depend on the transaction documents and the investor’s bargaining position.
PrimaryMarkets Male
The distinction matters. Choosing the company is only the beginning of understanding the investment.
Chapter 4
Funds Remain a Substantial Part of the Market
PrimaryMarkets Male
Australian venture capital provides a clear example of the continuing relevance of managed funds. In August 2026, Blackbird announced that its new funds had raised A$1.05 billion, split between early-stage and growth strategies. The separate pools are designed to support companies at different points in their development.
PrimaryMarkets Male
The broader lesson is that a fund can provide an organised programme of investment across multiple businesses and funding rounds. Investors gain access to a manager’s sourcing network, assessment process and capacity to support companies over time. Reproducing those capabilities independently may require considerable resources.
PrimaryMarkets Male
This is particularly relevant in early-stage investing, where commercial outcomes are uncertain and returns can depend heavily on a small number of successful companies. A portfolio approach can spread exposure across several opportunities, although it cannot eliminate investment losses or ensure that the manager selects eventual winners.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Delegation still requires scrutiny. Investors must assess the manager’s people, strategy, incentives and valuation practices, as well as the fund’s fees and terms. Historical returns need to be understood in context, including how much performance reflects realised cash proceeds and how much remains dependent on valuations of unsold holdings.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Fund investing transfers responsibility for individual investment decisions. It leaves the investor responsible for selecting and monitoring the manager.
Chapter 5
AustralianSuper Shows How the Approaches Can Work Together
PrimaryMarkets Male
AustralianSuper offers an institutional example of combining investment methods. Its published description of its private equity team includes investments in funds, co-investments and co-underwrites through relationships with private equity managers.
PrimaryMarkets Male
This illustrates the complementary nature of the approaches. A manager relationship can provide access to a wider portfolio and specialist expertise, while a co-investment allows additional capital to be allocated to a particular transaction. Different structures can serve different purposes within one investment programme.
PrimaryMarkets Male
The comparison has limits. An individual investor or smaller family office cannot assume it has the same negotiating position, analytical resources or access to transactions as a large superannuation fund. Institutional participation may also involve rights and terms unavailable to smaller shareholders.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Nevertheless, the principle is relevant: investors can delegate where external capabilities add value and retain more discretion where they have the resources to exercise it responsibly.
PrimaryMarkets Male
The appropriate balance depends on capability as much as conviction.
Chapter 6
Co-Investment Blurs the Boundary
PrimaryMarkets Male
Co-investment usually involves taking exposure to a specific business alongside a lead investor or financial sponsor. It can combine transaction-level selection with elements of the lead investor’s sourcing and execution capabilities, although the precise arrangement varies.
PrimaryMarkets Male
The boundary becomes less distinct when a managed fund itself invests in co-investments. In Australia, the Ironbark HarbourVest Diversified Private Equity Fund (AUD) provides wholesale investors with exposure through an underlying HarbourVest fund whose strategy focuses primarily on secondaries and direct co-investments. An investor therefore holds a fund interest, while the underlying portfolio includes transaction-specific company exposures.
PrimaryMarkets Male
This demonstrates why labels alone can be misleading. Investors need to understand the full ownership structure, where decisions are made and which fees apply at each level.
PrimaryMarkets Male
A co-investment should also be assessed on its own merits. A prominent lead investor does not remove the need to examine valuation, debt, shareholder rights and the exit assumptions. Participants should understand whether they invest on equivalent economic terms and how potential conflicts are managed.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Access to a transaction is useful only when the terms and underlying business withstand scrutiny.
Chapter 7
Fees Matter, but So Does the Cost of Doing the Work
PrimaryMarkets Male
The attraction of avoiding recurring fund management fees and carried interest is understandable. Over a long holding period, investment costs can materially affect the proceeds ultimately received by investors.
PrimaryMarkets Male
However, direct investment brings its own expenses. Legal review, financial analysis, technical due diligence, administration and ongoing monitoring all require either money or time. Depending on the structure, placement fees, platform charges or special-purpose vehicle expenses may also apply.
PrimaryMarkets Male
The relevant comparison is the total cost of acquiring and managing a comparable exposure. It should include the resources required to assess the opportunity properly and respond when circumstances change.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Scale affects that calculation. The cost of specialist due diligence may be manageable for a large investment but disproportionate for a small holding. Conversely, a fund’s fees may be difficult to justify if the manager provides limited access, weak reporting or an undifferentiated strategy.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Lower fees improve the economics of an otherwise equivalent investment. They cannot compensate for an excessive entry valuation, poor governance or an investment thesis that fails.
Chapter 8
Liquidity Must Be Assessed Separately
PrimaryMarkets Male
Neither direct ownership nor a fund structure automatically provides liquidity.
PrimaryMarkets Male
A direct shareholder may need to wait for a company sale, listing, buyback or permitted secondary transaction. Transfer restrictions can limit the ability to sell, and an interested buyer may only be willing to transact at a price below the shareholder’s expectations.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Closed-end funds generally distribute proceeds as investments are realised, subject to their governing documents. Investors may face a lengthy commitment, and extensions can prolong the holding period. Open-ended private market funds may provide withdrawal mechanisms, but their terms can include notice periods, limits, deferrals or suspensions.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Secondary transactions can introduce an additional option. They may allow an existing investor to seek an exit and a new investor to acquire an established holding. They do not create guaranteed demand or an assured price.
PrimaryMarkets Male
For a purchaser, a discount to an earlier funding round or reported asset value is a starting point for analysis. Changes in performance, capital requirements, debt and share-class rights may explain some or all of that discount.
PrimaryMarkets Male
An investment should remain supportable if an anticipated secondary exit does not occur.
Chapter 9
Diversification Requires a View Across the Whole Portfolio
PrimaryMarkets Male
Holding several investments does not necessarily mean holding several independent sources of risk.
PrimaryMarkets Male
An investor might own units in a venture fund, participate in a technology syndicate and purchase shares directly in another growth company. The structures differ, but all three exposures may depend on similar funding conditions, valuation assumptions and customer spending patterns.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Fund holdings can also overlap with direct positions. Without sufficient reporting, investors may underestimate their aggregate exposure to a company, sector or investment theme.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Cash-flow planning creates another connection. A fund commitment may involve future capital calls, while a direct investment may require additional funding to support growth or preserve an ownership percentage. Several portfolio companies seeking capital at the same time can place unexpected pressure on available cash.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Effective allocation therefore considers invested capital alongside outstanding commitments and potential follow-on requirements. It also allows for the possibility that distributions arrive later than expected.
PrimaryMarkets Male
The objective is a portfolio that remains manageable through difficult conditions, rather than one that appears diversified only when markets are supportive.
Chapter 10
What This Means for Wholesale and Sophisticated Investors
PrimaryMarkets Male
The expanding range of private market structures creates more ways to express an investment view. It also requires a clear understanding of which responsibilities remain with the investor.
PrimaryMarkets Male
A direct investment may suit an opportunity where the investor can assess the business, understand the terms and tolerate a concentrated, potentially illiquid exposure. A fund may be more appropriate where specialist sourcing, portfolio construction and ongoing management provide value that would be difficult to replicate independently. A combination may offer a practical way to pursue both objectives.
PrimaryMarkets Male
PrimaryMarkets provides access to capital raising and secondary trading opportunities in unlisted companies, alongside fund-related opportunities and Trading Hubs. These channels can help eligible investors consider different ways of participating in private markets. Each opportunity still requires its own assessment of risk, valuation, ownership structure and liquidity arrangements.
PrimaryMarkets Male
The allocation shift is best understood as a more deliberate choice about how capital is deployed and overseen. The enduring question is whether a particular structure improves the investor’s ability to understand the exposure, manage its risks and achieve an acceptable outcome after costs.
Chapter 11
About PrimaryMarkets
PrimaryMarkets Male
As private markets continue to evolve, investors and companies are increasingly seeking greater access, transparency and liquidity. PrimaryMarkets is an Australian-based platform that helps facilitate capital raising and secondary trading opportunities in private companies, managed funds and other unlisted investments.
PrimaryMarkets Male
Through its capital raising and trading solutions, PrimaryMarkets connects sophisticated and wholesale investors with a diverse range of private market opportunities across sectors including technology, healthcare, energy, resources, property and alternative assets. The platform also assists companies and fund managers to access growth capital while providing existing shareholders and unitholders with potential liquidity pathways.
PrimaryMarkets Male
By combining technology with market expertise, PrimaryMarkets is helping to modernise private capital markets, making it easier for investors to discover opportunities and for companies to connect with capital. As the private market ecosystem continues to mature, platforms such as PrimaryMarkets are playing an increasingly important role in improving access, facilitating transactions and supporting the efficient flow of capital.
Chapter 12
Close
PrimaryMarkets Male
And that brings us to the end of this episode of Unlocking Liquidity. Thanks for spending your time with us, we hope today’s conversation gave you a fresh perspective on private markets and how liquidity is evolving. If you enjoyed the episode, please follow or subscribe wherever you listen, and feel free to share it with someone who’d get value from it. For more insights, opportunities and episodes, visit PrimaryMarkets.com. Until next time, thanks for listening, and we’ll see you in the next conversation.