Unlocking Liquidity
All Episodes
Down Rounds Are Back - But They Look Different This Time

Down Rounds Are Back - But They Look Different This Time

0:00|0:00

A lower valuation tells you the price has changed. It doesn’t tell you the whole investment story.

In private markets, share rights, dilution, funding runway and liquidity can materially influence what an investment is worth—and what shareholders ultimately receive.

In this episode we explore why a lower-priced capital raising, an investor’s valuation markdown and a discounted secondary share sale need to be assessed differently.

With a focus on wholesale and sophisticated investors, we examine how to look beyond the headline valuation and assess the business and investment terms beneath it.


Chapter 1

Introduction

PrimaryMarkets Male

Welcome to Unlocking Liquidity, the PrimaryMarkets podcast exploring capital raising, unlisted shares and the changing dynamics of private markets.

PrimaryMarkets Male

A lower valuation can raise concerns, but it tells only part of the investment story. The rights attached to shares, the impact of dilution and the company’s future funding needs can be just as important as the price.

PrimaryMarkets Male

We examine how a down round differs from a valuation markdown or a discounted secondary sale, drawing on Australian market examples. We also consider when a valuation reset can help a company move forward, and what investors should assess before committing further capital.

PrimaryMarkets Male

For wholesale and sophisticated investors, understanding what sits behind the headline valuation is essential to evaluating the opportunity.

Chapter 2

A more selective valuation reset

PrimaryMarkets Male

For much of the private market boom, a higher valuation at each funding round was treated as evidence of progress. Growing revenue, ambitious expansion plans and strong investor demand supported an expectation that the next capital raising would take place at a higher price.

PrimaryMarkets Male

The adjustment that followed challenged that assumption. Companies discovered that operational progress did not necessarily protect them from falling valuations. A business could increase sales, strengthen its management team and improve its product while investors applied a lower multiple to its earnings or revenue.

PrimaryMarkets Male

However, the position in 2026 requires some qualification. Down rounds remain relevant, but the available evidence does not support a broad claim that they are accelerating across the market. Carta reported that 11.4% of funding rounds on its platform in the first quarter of 2026 were down rounds, returning to levels comparable with 2019 and 2020. More than 60% of capital raised in its dataset went to artificial intelligence companies, illustrating how unevenly the recovery is being distributed. These are platform-specific figures, rather than a measure of the Australian market.

PrimaryMarkets Male

The significance of down rounds today lies in that unevenness. Strong funding headlines can coexist with difficult negotiations for individual companies. For wholesale and sophisticated investors, understanding those negotiations requires attention to the business, the security being offered and the capital structure that will exist after the transaction.

Chapter 3

Understanding what has actually been repriced

PrimaryMarkets Male

A down round generally occurs when a company issues new shares at a lower price than in its previous financing, allowing for changes such as share splits. Although announcements often focus on the overall company valuation, the share price and associated rights provide a more useful basis for comparison.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Three events are frequently confused: a company raising new capital at a lower price, an investor reducing the carrying value of an existing investment, and a shareholder selling existing shares at a discount.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Each can signal changing expectations, but their consequences differ.

PrimaryMarkets Male

A primary capital raising brings money into the company and generally dilutes shareholders who do not participate. A valuation markdown changes an investor’s assessment of an existing holding without necessarily involving a transaction. A secondary sale transfers shares between investors, with the proceeds ordinarily going to the selling shareholder.

PrimaryMarkets Male

These distinctions matter when assessing whether a company is experiencing financial pressure. A discounted secondary transaction might reflect a seller’s need for liquidity, the rights attached to the shares or limited buyer demand. It does not, by itself, establish the price at which the company could raise fresh capital.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Similarly, a lower portfolio valuation does not necessarily indicate deteriorating operations. It may reflect changing market multiples or a more conservative assessment of future outcomes.

Chapter 4

Australia’s funding recovery is not uniform

PrimaryMarkets Male

Recent Australian data demonstrates why aggregate funding figures need careful interpretation.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Cut Through Venture reported A$4.2 billion in announced startup funding during the third quarter of 2026. However, Firmus accounted for A$2.85 billion, or approximately 69% of the quarterly total, through its AI infrastructure financing. Excluding that transaction, funding was approximately A$1.3 billion. Rounds below A$10 million contributed just 4% of total capital.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Firmus is an example of capital concentration, rather than a down-round case. Its relevance is that a record funding quarter does not establish that financing conditions have improved equally for every Australian business.

PrimaryMarkets Male

A smaller software company, an emerging manufacturer and a clinical-stage healthcare business may face very different investor expectations. Their access to capital depends on commercial progress, funding requirements, competitive conditions and the availability of investors comfortable with their particular risks.

PrimaryMarkets Male

The implication is that a market can support substantial valuation increases in selected companies while requiring others to accept lower prices or revise their financing plans. Investors should therefore be cautious about applying market-wide optimism to an individual opportunity.

Chapter 5

Australian valuation discipline offers another perspective

PrimaryMarkets Male

Blackbird provides a useful Australian example of how valuation practices have evolved.

PrimaryMarkets Male

In August 2022, the venture capital firm explained changes to its valuation methodology after sharp declines in listed technology markets. It reported that the aggregate valuation of its portfolio had fallen from A\$10 billion at the end of 2021 to A\$7.2 billion at June 2022. That movement reflected portfolio valuation adjustments, rather than evidence that every underlying company had completed a down round.

PrimaryMarkets Male

(https://www.blackbird.vc/blog/blackbirds-valuation-policy?utm_source=chatgpt.com)

PrimaryMarkets Male

In a March 2026 update, Blackbird stated that 70% of its portfolio by value was externally valued. It emphasised that valuations should respond to market conditions and that a declining valuation does not necessarily mean a company is failing.

PrimaryMarkets Male

(https://www.blackbird.vc/blog/four-years-on-how-our-valuation-policy-has-held-up?utm_source=chatgpt.com)

PrimaryMarkets Male

For investors in unlisted shares, this highlights the limitations of treating the last funding round as a permanent reference point.

PrimaryMarkets Male

A price negotiated several years earlier reflects the circumstances at that time. Since then, the company may have grown, consumed cash, taken on debt, encountered new competitors or changed its strategy. Listed peers may also be trading at different multiples.

PrimaryMarkets Male

An earlier valuation remains relevant historical information. Its usefulness as a guide to current value depends on what has changed.

Chapter 6

The headline valuation is only part of the economics

PrimaryMarkets Male

The financing tools used in difficult rounds are not new. Liquidation preferences, convertible instruments and anti-dilution provisions have long existed. What matters is how those tools interact with the company’s current position.

PrimaryMarkets Male

A company may preserve its headline valuation while offering new investors stronger economic rights. Depending on the transaction documents, those rights might include priority over earlier shareholders when proceeds are distributed following a sale.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Alternatively, a company may accept a visibly lower share price while retaining a simpler structure and more balanced rights. Comparing the two transactions solely by their announced valuations could produce a misleading conclusion.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Consider a simplified hypothetical investment of A$10 million for a 20% holding carrying a one-times, non-participating liquidation preference. If the company is subsequently sold and A$30 million is available for shareholders after debts and costs, the investor could receive its A$10 million preference instead of the A$6 million attributable to a 20% ordinary equity holding. This assumes no competing preferences and that the documents provide the relevant election.

PrimaryMarkets Male

The example illustrates why ownership percentage alone does not determine proceeds. Australian law firm Addisons explains that different preference classes can carry different economic rights, making the interaction between classes particularly important.

PrimaryMarkets Male

For an investor, the practical task is to model the distribution of proceeds across several exit values. A compelling company-level return may translate into a less attractive outcome for a particular share class.

Chapter 7

Dilution can extend beyond the new shares

PrimaryMarkets Male

The immediate consequence of a lower-priced raising is usually more shares being issued for a given amount of capital.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Suppose a company has 10 million shares on issue and raises A$10 million at A$1 per share. It issues another 10 million shares, leaving existing shareholders collectively owning 50% of the enlarged company, assuming they do not participate.

PrimaryMarkets Male

If the same amount were raised at A$2 per share, only five million new shares would be issued. Existing shareholders would retain approximately 66.7%.

PrimaryMarkets Male

However, those calculations can understate the full impact. Existing preference shareholders may have anti-dilution protections that adjust their conversion terms following a qualifying lower-priced issue. Addisons distinguishes between full-ratchet and weighted-average mechanisms and notes that broad-based weighted-average protection is more common in Australia.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Convertible securities and changes to employee option pools can also alter the final ownership position. Consequently, the relevant document is a fully diluted capitalisation table showing the position after the proposed financing and all related adjustments.

PrimaryMarkets Male

That analysis should establish both the investor’s ownership and the claims ranking ahead of it.

Chapter 8

A bridge should lead to a measurable destination

PrimaryMarkets Male

When a company wishes to postpone a priced round, it may seek a bridge through convertible notes, SAFEs or other interim financing arrangements.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Such instruments can serve a legitimate purpose. A business approaching a major customer contract, regulatory milestone or production launch may benefit from sufficient funding to complete that work before negotiating a larger equity round.

PrimaryMarkets Male

However, postponing a valuation discussion does not remove the underlying financing requirement. Conversion discounts, valuation caps and, where applicable, accrued interest can influence the eventual ownership outcome. Several overlapping instruments can make that outcome difficult to assess without detailed modelling.

PrimaryMarkets Male

The commercial question is what the additional time is expected to achieve.

PrimaryMarkets Male

A bridge that funds a defined milestone with a credible budget has a different risk profile from one that simply extends operations while management waits for improved market sentiment. Investors need to understand the fallback position if the milestone is delayed or the next round cannot be completed.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Funding runway is valuable when it enables progress that changes the business’s prospects. Time alone does not resolve an unsustainable operating model.

Chapter 9

A lower valuation can support a stronger business

PrimaryMarkets Male

A down round can be a constructive response to changed circumstances when it provides adequate capital and accompanies a credible operating reset.

PrimaryMarkets Male

A company that raised on ambitious expansion assumptions may subsequently identify a narrower, more profitable opportunity. It may reduce spending, exit weaker markets and concentrate on customers with better retention and margins. A lower valuation can help align the financing with that revised strategy.

PrimaryMarkets Male

The crucial distinction is between a business whose earlier price was too optimistic and one whose commercial foundations are weakening.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Evidence matters more than the size of the discount. Revenue quality, customer concentration, gross margins, working capital requirements and cash consumption help establish whether the new capital can support a sustainable improvement.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Management incentives also deserve attention. Heavy dilution and accumulated preference rights can reduce the value of employee and founder equity at achievable exit prices. Refreshing incentives may help retain the people needed to deliver the plan, although it can create further dilution and requires careful implementation. Australian legal guidance identifies both incentive alignment and the interaction of financing terms as material considerations in a down round.

PrimaryMarkets Male

An attractive financing should leave the business capable of execution, with a realistic budget and meaningful incentives for its team.

Chapter 10

Secondary liquidity brings a different price signal

PrimaryMarkets Male

For investors in unlisted companies, secondary transactions can provide evidence of what buyers will pay for an existing holding under current conditions.

PrimaryMarkets Male

That evidence needs context. Ordinary shares may have different rights from the preference shares issued in the most recent funding round. Information access, transfer restrictions, transaction size and the expected holding period can also influence pricing.

PrimaryMarkets Male

A discount to the last announced valuation is therefore a starting point for investigation, rather than proof of a bargain.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Secondary transactions can nevertheless serve a useful purpose. They may allow an existing shareholder to realise part of an investment while another investor takes a longer-term position. The company can remain private without requiring every shareholder to maintain the same investment horizon.

PrimaryMarkets Male

This is relevant to the distinction between capital raising and trading unlisted shares. One funds the company; the other can provide shareholder liquidity. Both require clear information about the security and its rights, and neither guarantees an eventual exit or a particular return.

Chapter 11

Assessing the opportunity after the reset

PrimaryMarkets Male

For wholesale and sophisticated investors, the central question is whether the proposed investment offers an acceptable relationship between price, rights, business quality and future funding risk.

PrimaryMarkets Male

A substantial discount can still leave an investment expensive if revenue is deteriorating or further dilution is likely. Conversely, a lower-priced round may create a credible entry point where the business has demonstrable customer demand, improved financial discipline and sufficient capital to execute its plan.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Investors should also consider how the outcome changes if growth is slower, the next financing is delayed or an exit occurs below management’s expectations. The shareholding’s position in those scenarios is more informative than a comparison with the company’s highest historical valuation.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Down rounds are part of the continuing adjustment of private capital markets. Their significance today is shaped by selective funding, more explicit valuation discipline and the interaction between different shareholder rights.

PrimaryMarkets Male

For participants in capital raisings and unlisted share transactions through PrimaryMarkets, the task is to assess the investment as it stands now: what the business can achieve, what the capital will fund and what the investor’s security is entitled to receive.

Chapter 12

About PrimaryMarkets

PrimaryMarkets Male

As private markets continue to evolve, investors and companies are increasingly seeking greater access, transparency and liquidity. PrimaryMarkets is an Australian-based platform that helps facilitate capital raising and secondary trading opportunities in private companies, managed funds and other unlisted investments.

PrimaryMarkets Male

Through its capital raising and trading solutions, PrimaryMarkets connects sophisticated and wholesale investors with a diverse range of private market opportunities across sectors including technology, healthcare, energy, resources, property and alternative assets. The platform also assists companies and fund managers to access growth capital while providing existing shareholders and unitholders with potential liquidity pathways.

PrimaryMarkets Male

By combining technology with market expertise, PrimaryMarkets is helping to modernise private capital markets, making it easier for investors to discover opportunities and for companies to connect with capital. As the private market ecosystem continues to mature, platforms such as PrimaryMarkets are playing an increasingly important role in improving access, facilitating transactions and supporting the efficient flow of capital.

Chapter 13

Close

PrimaryMarkets Male

And that brings us to the end of this episode of Unlocking Liquidity. Thanks for spending your time with us, we hope today’s conversation gave you a fresh perspective on private markets and how liquidity is evolving. If you enjoyed the episode, please follow or subscribe wherever you listen, and feel free to share it with someone who’d get value from it. For more insights, opportunities and episodes, visit PrimaryMarkets.com. Until next time, thanks for listening, and we’ll see you in the next conversation.